Sourdough Apple Butter Muffins

Last Updated on November 13, 2024

If it’s possible to recreate a taste of autumn in New England in a recipe, these Sourdough Apple Butter Muffins will take you there in one bite.

From apple picking, hay rides, to leaf peeping, fall is probably my favorite season in New England. And with multiple apple orchards surrounding my home, I’m never in short supply of mountain crisp apples.

This easy sourdough apple muffins recipe includes apples in two ways: fresh apples in the batter and apple butter. In addition, I use sourdough discard in the muffins for a slightly tangy flavor akin to buttermilk or yogurt.

Using apple butter and sourdough discard results in an extremely moist sourdough apple muffin with a concentration of apple flavor that isn’t too sweet.

Apple pie spices like cinnamon, ginger, cardamom, and clove complement the apples and perfume your kitchen as they bake.

And a Biscoff cookie and oat streusel top off the apple muffins for an ambrosial experience.

For such a big payoff, it’s hard to believe how easy these sourdough apple muffins are to make.

---

👨‍🍳 Tips for Making the Best Sourdough Apple Butter Muffins

1. Make the Streusel Ahead of Time

• Streusel can be made ahead of time. It stores for 3-4 days in the refrigerator! Above all, it’s easy to make. It’s a great topping to have on hand for other desserts such as coffee cake, fruit crisp, or pie.
• For a tender streusel or crumble, use cold butter and keep the streusel refrigerated. Cold streusel also results in larger crumbs, which I prefer for this recipe. On the other hand, if you’re a fan of a sandier crumble, use melted butter.

2. Don’t Overmix the Muffin Batter

• Just like making these Sourdough Bran Muffins or Sourdough Irish Soda Bread, a tender muffin is made by not overmixing the batter. Overmixing results in gluten development, which is suitable for bread, but not for pastries, cakes, or muffins.
• Therefore, only mix the muffin batter until the wet and dry ingredients are incorporated. It’s okay if a few dry spots of flour remain. Lastly, fold in the apples, which will hydrate the rest of the flour.

3. Bake at a High Temperature

• To get bakery-style muffins that rise tall and have classic muffin tops like my Sourdough Blueberry Yogurt Muffins, you need to bake the muffins at a high temperature. Baking at a high temperature works because the heat immediately creates steam in the batter, which causes the baking powder and soda to expand quickly in the oven. This quick, initial rise in the batter is also known as oven spring.
• I bake these muffins at 400ºF for 16-18 minutes.

4. Use Homemade Apple Butter if Possible

• There’s nothing like homemade apple butter. For baking, it lets you control the spices, flavors, and sweetness of your apple butter. Many fall farmer’s markets and orchards often sell their apple butter, which I recommend.
• Store-bought apple butter often contains added sugar and spices; the levels can vary wildly. Depending on how sweet and spiced your apple butter is, you may want to cut down the sugar and spices in half for this recipe. At any rate, there are good store-bought apple butter options. For example, this Eden apple butter is my preferred choice.

5. Use Baking Apples

• Red Delicious apples don’t have much flavor, can be mealy, and get mushy when baked. In contrast, use tart, hard-fleshed baking apples for the best muffins or other baked goods. They will still keep some of their texture and tartness when baked.
• For instance, Granny Smith, Pink Lady, Braeburn, or Honeycrisp are solid options.

---

🛠 Tools Needed

Click on the toggles below for more information, recommendations, and possible substitutes.

• Muffin Pan: This sourdough muffin recipe makes 12 standard muffins. A standard muffin pan will work just fine.
• Baking Scale: Ingredients like sourdough discard can weigh differently by volume, so weight measurements are much more accurate and consistent.
• Muffin Liners: These Tulip muffin liners help the muffins rise taller and make for a great presentation. You can use regular muffin or cupcake liners, though the muffins might be more stout. If you don’t have liners, just be sure to oil and flour your muffin pan well!

---

🛒 Ingredients Needed

Click on the toggles below for more information, recommendations, and possible substitutions.

Sourdough Apple Butter Muffins

• All-purpose flour: Can substitute some with whole wheat flour if you’d like.
• Apple butter: Make your own homemade apple butter!
• Apples:
  • As mentioned in the tips section, use tart, hard-fleshed baking apples in this recipe. Granny Smith, Braeburn, Pink Lady, and Honeycrisp are good easily found options.
  • I prefer fresh, in-season fruit in recipes like these muffins and my Sourdough Strawberries & Cream Scones for the best flavor.
• Sourdough discard: Learn How to Make a Sourdough Starter and make a stronger sourdough starter with my top sourdough starter tips. Get other sourdough discard recipes here.
• Spices:
  • I use ground cinnamon, ginger, cardamom, and cloves in this recipe to make the spiced muffins. Cinnamon is present in the Biscoff cookies, but I add more in the streusel and batter for a nice apple cinnamon flavor.
  • If you don’t have one of the other spices, skip it. Moreover, apple pie spice is a suitable substitute.
• Light Brown Sugar
• Baking Powder: Mechanical leaveners help the muffins rise
• Baking Soda
• Salt
• Melted Unsalted Butter
• Eggs
• Vanilla extract

Biscoff Streusel Topping

• Biscoff Cookies:
  • Lotus Biscoff cookies are Belgian speculoos cookies (biscuits). They have a snickerdoodle/cinnamon flavor and are similar to graham crackers (which you can also use).
• Cinnamon
• Light Brown Sugar
• Unsalted Butter

---

🍎 How to Make Sourdough Apple Butter Muffins

Follow this visual and detailed guide to help you make the best Sourdough Apple Muffins.

1. Make Biscoff Streusel

• Use a food processor or hands to crumble the Biscoff cookies until they’re a fine, sandy texture.
• Mix the crumbled cookies in a medium bowl with the rolled oats, cinnamon, and light brown sugar.
• Cut the cold unsalted butter into small cubes.
• Toss the butter cubes in the bowl and use your hands to squeeze the streusel together until small clumps form. The streusel will still be dry, but no butter or flour should be visible.
• Lastly, cover the bowl with a lid and store the streusel in the refrigerator for up to 3 days.

2. Preheat Oven and Prepare Muffin Pan

Preheat the oven to 400ºF (204ºC).

Prepare a standard 12-cup muffin pan by lining it with muffin cup liners. You can use any type of muffin liner, but I get the best results with these tulip liners– the muffins rise taller!

Alternatively, lightly grease your muffin pan with butter or oil. Then, evenly sprinkle a few pinches of flour into the pan, shake, and dump any excess flour.

3. Mix Dry Ingredients

In a large bowl, mix the following dry ingredients including the all-purpose flour, salt, baking powder, baking soda, and spices.

Set aside.

4. Mix Wet Ingredients

In a medium-sized bowl, whisk together the apple butter, sourdough discard, light brown sugar, eggs, and vanilla extract.

Set aside.

5. Dice Apples and Mix Muffin Batter

Dice the apples and set aside. You will fold the apples in last.

Pour all of the wet ingredients into the large bowl of dry ingredients.

Mix the muffin batter with a spatula or whisk until you only see a few spots of flour remaining. Don’t overmix.

Use a spatula to gently fold in the diced apples until evenly distributed in the batter. This should only take a few folds, and it will hydrate the remaining flour.

6. Bake

Use a spoon or a ¼ measuring cup to distribute the muffin batter into the prepared pans evenly. As you’re scooping, ensure a few diced apples go into each muffin cup.

Finally, remove the cold streusel from the refrigerator and evenly sprinkle it on the muffins. It will look like a lot of streusel crumble, but the surface area of the muffin tops will increase as they bake.

Bake the muffins at 400ºF (204ºC) for 16-20 minutes until the tops are light brown and a toothpick or cake tester inserted into the middle of a muffin comes out clean.

If you’re using the tulip liners I recommend, the muffins will rise taller but will take longer to bake (20 minutes for me).

Cool the muffins completely on a wire rack.

---

How to Serve

These sourdough apple muffins are delicious on their own as a snack or served with a fall breakfast. They’re great gifts, and easy and quick breakfast treats for a crowd!

If you really want to jazz them up, split the muffins in half and toast them face-side down in a frying pan with a slab of butter. I couldn’t recommend it enough.

Furthermore, you can serve the muffins with more apple butter as a spread.

---

How to Store

These sourdough apple muffins stay moist for days! In addition, the apple butter and sourdough discard help preserve them longer than traditional muffins, just like my Sourdough Blueberry Yogurt Muffins, Sourdough Cranberry Yogurt Muffins, and Sourdough Bran Muffins.

Keep the muffins in a zip-lock bag or airtight container with a paper towel for up to 3-4 days. Paper towels help prevent sogginess.

I don’t recommend refrigerating muffins as the texture will change, and they dry out quicker.

For more extended storage, freeze the apple butter muffins in a single layer for up to a few months. Then, defrost the muffins overnight at room temperature or warm them in a microwave or conventional oven.

---

❓FAQs:

---

---

---

Other Recipes You Might Like: