This post may contain affiliate links for products and ingredients I use and recommend. For more information, see my affiliate disclosures.
- What is Brioche?
- What is Yudane?
- 🛠 Tools Needed for Sourdough Brioche:
- 🛒 Ingredients Needed for Sourdough Brioche:
- 👨🏫 Baker's Percentage Table:
- 👨🍳 How to Make Sourdough Brioche Recipe & Guide:
- How to Serve Sourdough Brioche Bread:
- How to Store Sourdough Brioche Bread:
- Sourdough Brioche Bread FAQs:
- Sourdough Brioche Bread
- Other Recipes You May Enjoy:
This Sourdough Brioche Bread recipe makes the best soft, fluffy, and buttery bread! Using the Yudane method, this sourdough brioche is extra tender and keeps the bread pillowy and fresh for days.
Inspired by Japanese Shokupan or Japanese Milk Bread, this sourdough brioche is an enriched bread made with eggs, milk, a little sugar, and butter. The brioche even has a shreddable, pull-apart texture like store-bought dinner rolls.
Sourdough Brioche is so light that it practically melts in your mouth just looking at it. The long fermentation from sourdough gives it a slight tang and is balanced by a slight sweetness and of course the buttery-ness of it all.
Brioche is great alone, with jam, as breakfast toast, or as French Toast. It’s a versatile and staple recipe in my house and I even use the dough to make my Sourdough Cinnamon Rolls. It’s that good! Master this sourdough brioche recipe and a whole collection of enriched dough recipes will open before you!
What is Brioche?
Brioche is a French bread that is highly enriched with eggs and butter. With its high butter content, brioche is in the same family of yeasted baked goods like croissants and puff pastry- viennoiserie.
Brioche can be a single loaf, braided, made as rolls, or as individual muffin-like servings. It’s versatile to serve on its own or to use the dough as a base for other recipes like babkas, cinnamon rolls, dinner rolls, or even sourdough hamburger buns.
What is Yudane?
Yudane is a Japanese method of mixing flour and boiling water together that creates an extremely soft bread. This simple roux gelatinizes the flour into a paste and has many benefits when trying to create an extra soft bread. The pre-cooked flour allows it to absorb more water, helps the dough rise taller, and makes it more shelf-stable.
Yudane is similar to Tangzhong (a Chinese method of pre-cooking flour on a stovetop into a slurry) and both translate into “roux” in their respective languages. Yudane is a 1:1 ratio of flour and water whereas Tangzhong is typically a 1:5 ratio.
For this Sourdough Brioche Bread recipe, I prefer the Yudane method because you can make it at the same time as your levain and let it cool while your levain rises.
🛠 Tools Needed for Sourdough Brioche:
Click on the toggles below for more information, recommendations, and possible substitutes.
Baking Scale
I always list ingredients by weight in grams because it is the most accurate way to measure ingredients. Use a scale and your baking will immediately be better! I love my Escali baking scale and use it every day. The batteries last a long time, it’s accurate, and it comes in many different colors.
Stand Mixer
Invest in a high-quality stand mixer and it will last a very long time. I use my KitchenAid stand mixer all the time for baking projects.
To develop enough gluten and thoroughly mix in the softened butter for this recipe, a stand mixer with a bread hook will do that job for you. Making brioche by hand will take an extremely long time to properly knead by hand and I would not recommend making this recipe without a stand mixer.
The Artisan KitchenAid is the one I use because its motor is strong enough for all of my baking projects, the bowl has a handle (the classic does not), comes in an array of colors, and looks great on any kitchen counter.
Bread Loaf Pan
This 9″ USA Pullman Pan is my absolute favorite bread pan for this sourdough brioche. The USA Pan brand is heavy gauge quality steel, nonstick, and made in the United States of course. This pullman pan has tall, straight sides which I love for brioche recipes and milk breads.
A 9×5″ bread loaf pan also works here. I wouldn’t use a smaller bread loaf pan for this recipe because it might overfill the pan.
Pastry Brush
This sourdough brioche gets an egg wash to give it a slight shine. This Oxo pastry brush is very good. You could also use an unused paint brush if you don’t have or want to buy a pastry brush right now.
Optional but helpful: Brød & Taylor Folding Proofer
This folding proofing box by Brød & Taylor is a game changer to keep your sourdough starter and doughs at the perfect temperature while proofing. It folds up easily, includes a humidity tray, and can even be used as a slow cooker.
🛒 Ingredients Needed for Sourdough Brioche:
Click on the toggles below for more information, recommendations, and possible substitutes.
Bread Flour
Brioche requires a lot of gluten strength in order to rise properly. I use King Arthur Bread Flour here because of its 12.7% protein content and is the best quality bread flour typically found in grocery stores in New England. Another high-quality and high-protein content bread flour would work as well.
Sourdough Starter
Don’t have a sourdough starter? Be sure to follow my How to Make a Sourdough Starter guide to learn how to make and maintain your own in just a week.
- Granulated Sugar
- Sea Salt
- Whole Milk
- Eggs
- Unsalted Butter
👨🏫 Baker’s Percentage Table:
I include a baker’s percentage chart so you can easily scale a recipe up or down. With baker’s percentages, the total weight of all flour in the recipe is 100%. The other ingredients are noted in relation to the total weight of flour. This is why the percentages below will add up to over 100%. The King Arthur website has a more detailed reference page on why and how baker’s percentages are calculated if you’re interested and would like to learn more.
Dough Ingredients | Weight | Percentage |
---|---|---|
Bread Flour | 270 grams | 100% |
Sourdough Starter* | 30 grams | 11.1% |
Water | 88 grams | 32.6% |
Sea Salt | 5 grams | 1.9% |
Granulated Sugar | 27 grams | 1.0% |
Whole Milk, room temperature | 59 grams | 21.9% |
Two Large Eggs** | 114 grams | 42.2% |
Unsalted Butter, room temperature | 113 grams (8 TBS/One stick) | 41.9% |
If you do not want to build a levain, use about 80-90g starter instead.
**Another egg is used for egg wash
👨🍳 How to Make Sourdough Brioche Recipe & Guide:
I’ve included a sample schedule alongside this sourdough brioche guide. As always, adjust as necessary to fit your own schedule, ambient temperature, and rate of fermentation.
1. Build the Levain: 9:00am
Mix together 30g sourdough starter, 30g bread flour, and 30g warm water in an empty jar.
Cover and let set in a warm location (between 75-80ºF) for about five hours until bubbly and ripe. The levain should at least double in size during this time.
Note: Please refer to my guide on How To Make A Sourdough Starter if you do not have a sourdough starter and the FAQ section on that page where I explain the difference between a starter and a levain. Learn how to make a stronger sourdough starter with my sourdough starter tips guide.
I almost always use a specific levain for recipes. If you’d prefer to skip making a levain, just use about 80-90g ripe sourdough starter when you add the wet ingredients.
2. Make Yudane: 9:05am
Make your yudane for this sourdough brioche recipe at the same time as you make your levain (or at least 5 hours before you make the dough).
Place 58g bread flour in a small, heatproof bowl.
Boil 58g water in a tea kettle or on a stovetop. Immediately pour the boiling water on top of the flour.
With a silicone spatula, mix together the flour and boiling water until the flour is gelatinized, thoroughly mixed, and it forms a thick paste.
Set aside to cool. This is your yudane!
Note: Typically, yudane sits for at least 8 hours or overnight before adding to your dough. For this recipe though, I find making it at the same time as your levain is easier and works just as well.
3. Mix Together Sourdough Brioche Bread Ingredients: 2:00pm
Once the levain is ripe, add the following ingredients into the bowl of a stand mixer:
- 212 grams bread flour
- 27 grams granulated sugar
- 5 grams salt
- 59 grams whole milk at room temperature
- All of the ripe levain (or about 80-90 grams sourdough starter)
- All of the cooled yudane (about 116 grams total)
- Two large eggs
Set aside 113g unsalted butter (one stick) to come to room temperature while you begin mixing.
With the dough hook attached and the stand mixer on low speed, begin mixing the dough together.
At first, the dough will be dry until the flour starts to get hydrated. After a few minutes, the dough will be wet and shaggy.
Increase the speed to medium and continue mixing for about five more minutes. When done, the dough should be smoother, more cohesive and mostly clearing the sides of the bowl.
Scrape down the sides of the bowl if needed.
4. Add Butter and Mix: 2:10pm
When making most enriched breads using butter like this brioche, it’s very important that the butter be softened at room temperature (68-70ºF). Room temperature butter will incorporate best into the dough. You’ll know the butter is soft enough when it leaves a slight impression or indentation if you press on it with your finger.
Slice the 113 grams (one stick, or 8 TBS) of room temperature unsalted butter into at least eight pieces.
With the mixer on medium speed, add the butter one piece at a time until it is fully incorporated into the dough. Let the dough mix at least a minute or two before adding in the next piece of butter.
As you’re mixing, the dough should scrape the butter against the sides of the mixing bowl.
Adding the butter should take at least 10 minutes in total. During this time, the dough will be developing more gluten which is essential in this highly enriched recipe so the brioche will rise properly.
Once the butter is added, continue mixing for about five or so minutes or until the dough is silky smooth, does not stick to your finger, easily slides off the dough hook, and passes the windowpane test.
What is the windowpane test?
The windowpane test is a useful tool to know if enough gluten has been developed in a dough.
To perform the windowpane test, gently pull up a small portion of the dough between your fingers. If the dough quickly tears, it has not developed enough gluten (first photo below). Mix the dough a few more minutes at a time.
The dough passes the windowpane test if you’re able to stretch it into a thin, translucent film that light could pass through without breaking (second photo below).
Why do you add butter last when making enriched breads?
Fat like butter or oil inhibits initial gluten development in dough. Mixing the dough before adding in the fat will help the dough develop and maintain its gluten network. This is why enriched bread recipes like brioche have you add butter at the end of mixing.
5. Bulk Fermentation: 2:30pm-6:30pm (about 5 hours at 78ºF)
Transfer the dough to a medium mixing bowl, gather into a round, cover, and place in a warm location to proof for bulk fermentation. My Brød & Taylor proofer works perfectly for this.
Stretch & Fold: 3:30pm
After one hour, perform a series of stretch and folds in the dough.
Simply pull up a portion of the dough in four different sections and fold it down onto itself.
The stretch & fold will help the strengthen the dough and gather it a little better in the bowl during bulk fermentation (first proof).
If you notice the dough is still very slack after another hour, feel free to add an additional stretch & fold.
Proof the dough about 5 hours total at 78ºF until it is about doubled, domed, you see a few bubbles on top, and is even smoother.
Notes:
- Because this is an enriched dough, it can take longer to proof. Ideally, the dough is placed in a warm & humid environment like a bread proofer or in an oven with the light turned on. 75-80ºF is the ideal temperature range for sourdough yeasts. If cooler, the dough will take longer to proof. If warmer, it will proof faster.
- Unlike My Everyday Sourdough Bread recipe, this dough is unlikely to overproof unless left in a warm environment for hours longer than called for (in which case the dough can spoil). You will degas the dough the next day, so getting this first proof exactly correct is less critical than making an artisan-style sourdough bread.
6. Cold Overnight Proof: 6:30pm
There are many benefits of chilling this dough overnight.
First, the cold proof, or retard, slows down fermentation and gives the sourdough brioche bread a more complex flavor.
Secondly, rolling out chilled dough is much easier than rolling out room temperature dough.
Lastly, proofing it overnight allows you bake it at a later time that best fits your schedule.
With the dough covered, place in a cold refrigerator for an overnight proof and up to two days.
Note: If proofing for longer than overnight, keep your dough in the coldest part of your refrigerator. The coldest part of a refrigerator is is typically a bottom back corner.
7. Divide and Shape Sourdough Brioche Dough: Next day at 9:00am
Prep Pan
Butter or spray your bread loaf pan with a nonstick cooking spray. If you’re using the 9″ USA Pullman Pan that I recommend, you don’t need to butter the pan as it will not stick.
Degas Dough
Take the chilled dough out of the refrigerator, punch it down with your hand to degas it (fun!).
Divide Dough
Turn the dough out onto a lightly floured work surface. It should be easy to remove from the bowl, but use a bowl scraper to get any remaining bits if needed.
Using a knife or bench scraper, divide the dough into four equally sized pieces. They should be around 170-175g each.
Shape Dough
Working on a floured surface and with one portion at a time, pat the brioche dough into a small rectangle (about 3″x5″).
Roll up the dough, starting from the short side nearest you, into a cylinder (like you’re rolling a mini cinnamon bun roll).
Place seam side down in the prepared bread loaf pan and repeat with the remaining three pieces.
The pieces should fit evenly and snugly into the pan.
8. Final Proof: 9:15am (about 5 hours at 78ºF)
Cover the loaf pan and place in a warm location for its final proof like a bread proofer or an oven with the light turned on.
At 78ºF, proofing typically takes about 5 hours for this sourdough brioche dough. It can be a little sluggish because of the high amount of butter in the dough and has taken about 30 minutes or more to proof before for me.
At the end of proofing, the dough should be doubled and feel full of air. If you take a floured finger and gently poke it, it should leave a slight indentation.
In my tall-sided 9″ USA Pullman Pan (4″ height), the dough rises about 1″ below the rim. In a shorter side, typical bread loaf pan, it might rise about an inch over the rim.
9. Bake: 2:15pm
Preheat oven to 400ºF.
When the oven is preheated, beat an egg and a splash of water together in a small bowl to create an egg wash.
Using a pastry brush, brush the top of the proofed brioche with a light egg wash.
Once the oven is preheated, place the bread loaf pan in the oven and immediately turn down the oven temperature to 350ºF.
Preheating the oven to 400ºF will give the bread a better oven spring/initial rise. 400ºF is a little too hot though to bake brioche, so that’s why I call to lower the temperature to 350ºF. I found this process gave the best results for me without getting the crust too dark!
Bake for about 45 minutes or until the top of the dough is golden brown. The internal temperature should read 195-205ºF when done if using an instant read thermometer.
Let cool in the pan on a wire rack for about 10 minutes. Turn the loaf out of the pan and let it cool completely on the wire rack- at least an hour.
There is high moisture content in this soft sourdough brioche bread and the steam from the loaf can get trapped in the pan if left to cool completely in the pan. This steam can make the exterior of the dough a little soggy or cause the dough to shrink a lot (some shrinkage is normal though). That’s why I call to completely cool the loaf out of the loaf pan.
Pull apart or slice and enjoy!
How to Serve Sourdough Brioche Bread:
This sourdough brioche is so light and has so much rich flavor, that I prefer to eat it day of on its own or just with a simple berry jam. It really is the best sourdough brioche!
After the second day, it’s excellent buttery toast or even French Toast. Sign up for my newsletter to receive my Sourdough Challah French Toast recipe which you could easily substitute this brioche bread for!
How to Store Sourdough Brioche Bread:
Because of the high amount of butter, eggs, and milk in this recipe, enriched doughs can stay quite soft for a few days if stored properly. By using the yudane method too, this sourdough brioche bread can last up to five days!
As most breads, sourdough brioche is best day of. After slicing, it can keep wrapped at room temperature for up to five days. Sliced side down is the best way to keep most breads to prevent additional moisture from escaping. Reheat slices or toast slightly to soften the brioche.
This sourdough brioche also freezes well. Slice the entire loaf and store in a freezer safe bag for at least a couple months.
Sourdough Brioche Bread FAQs:
Can I double this recipe?
This recipe makes one brioche loaf. You’re welcome to double this recipe! Simply double the amount of ingredients, and divide the dough into eight pieces instead of four. Follow the rest of the recipe the same
Why do you use the yudane method here?
I use yudane to make the brioche extra soft and give it a pull-apart texture. Yudane also helps the bread keep longer. You could use tangzhong but I find yudane to be a little easier and saves needing to wash a pot during the process.
Why did my brioche shrink or collapse?
For breads this light, it’s normal for the bread to shrink slightly when cooling. Be sure to let the bread cool out of its pan so it doesn’t shrink more. It shouldn’t affect the flavor though.
The dough could have also overproofed. Overproofed breads can expand very fast in the oven but quickly run out of gas (food/yeasts to eat) and then deflate at a certain point in the oven or when cooling. Next time, end proofing a little earlier.
Could I shape this brioche bread differently?
Sure! Brioche can be shaped in many ways. I happen to like the milk bread style rolled up in a tall loaf pan. The brioche could be divided in two and braided together in the pan. You could also split the dough into 8 equal sized spheres and place the rounds into the loaf pan.
My butter is too cold or warm?
If your butter is too warm or cold, it will have a hard time incorporating into the dough. It’s important that the butter be at room temperature or at the temperature where you can lightly press with your finger and it will leave an impression.
If you need to slightly warm butter, you can zap in the microwave for five seconds at a time so it doesn’t melt. Too warm? Throw into the freezer for a couple minutes at a time.
Sourdough Brioche Bread
Equipment
- 1 Bread Loaf Pan, I prefer the 9" USA Pullman Pan for straight sides but you can also use a 9"x5" bread loaf pan
- 1 Brød and Taylor Folding Proofer, optional, but helpful
Ingredients
Levain
- 30 grams Sourdough Starter
- 30 grams Bread Flour
- 30 grams Warm Water
Yudane
- 58 grams Bread Flour
- 58 grams Boiling Water
Sourdough Brioche Bread Dough
- 212 grams Bread Flour
- 27 grams Granulated Sugar
- 5 grams Sea Salt
- Levain, see above, or use 90g of active sourdough starter
- Yudane, see above
- 59 grams Whole Milk, room temperature
- 2 Eggs
- 113 grams Unsalted Butter, One stick or 8 TBS, room temperature
Egg Wash
- 1 Egg
- 1 tsp Water
Instructions
- Build the Levain:Mix together the sourdough starter, bread flour, and warm water in a clean and empty jar. Cover and let it sit in a warm location for about five hours until doubled, bubbly, and ripe.30 grams Sourdough Starter, 30 grams Bread Flour, 30 grams Warm Water
- Make the Yudane:Make the yudane at the same time as you build the levain or at least five hours before you make the dough.Place 58 grams of bread flour in a small heatproof bowl. Boil 58 grams of boiling water in a tea kettle or on a stovetop and pour the boiling water directly onto the flour. Mix together with a small spatula until the mixture is gelatinized and forms a thick paste. Set aside to cool.58 grams Bread Flour, 58 grams Boiling Water
- Mix the Sourdough Brioche Bread Dough:When your levain is ripe, mix together all of the dough ingredients except the butter in the bowl of a stand mixer with a dough hook.Mix on low speed until it begins to form a shaggy dough. Increase the speed to medium and mix for about five minutes. When done, the dough should be smoother and mostly clear the sides of the bowl. Scrape down the sides if needed.212 grams Bread Flour, 27 grams Granulated Sugar, 5 grams Sea Salt, Levain, Yudane, 59 grams Whole Milk, 2 Eggs
- Add Butter:Slice the softened butter into at least 8 pieces (about 1 TBS each). With the mixer on medium speed, add one piece of butter at a time until it is fully incorporated into the dough. Let the dough mix for at least a minute or two before adding in the next piece of butter. This should take at least 10 minutes in total.Once all the pieces are added, continue to mix for at least five more minutes until the dough is silky smooth, does not stick to your finger, and easily slides off the dough hook. The dough should pass the windowpane test (please refer to the guide for windowpane test photos and explanation). If your dough seems a little weak after mixing, it will continue to build strength as it ferments.113 grams Unsalted Butter
- Bulk Fermentation:Transfer the dough to a medium mixing bowl, gather into a round, cover, and place in a warm location to proof about 5 hours in total at 78ºF.
- Stretch & Fold:After the first hour, perform a series of stretch & folds in the dough. Simply pull up a portion of the dough in four different sections and fold it down upon itself. Add another stretch & fold after another hour if you notice the dough is still very slack.
- Overnight Proof:After five hours or when the dough has doubled, domed, and you likely see a couple of bubbles on top, place the dough in a cold spot of your refrigerator for the overnight proof.Proof the dough for at least 8 hours and up to 48 hours in the refrigerator.
- Divide Dough:The next day, butter or spray your bread loaf pan with nonstick cooking spray.Remove the chilled brioche dough from the refrigerator and punch it down with a fist to degas it.Then, turn the dough out onto a lightly floured work surface.Using a knife or bench scraper, divide the dough into four equally sized pieces. They should be around 170-175g each.
- Shape Dough:Working on a floured surface and one piece at a time, pat the dough into a small rectangle (about 3″x5″).Roll up the dough, starting from the short side nearest you, into a cylinder.Place seam side down in the prepared bread loaf pan and repeat with the remaining three pieces.The pieces should fit evenly and snugly into the pan.
- Final Proof:Keep the dough covered in a warm location for its final proof. The final proof should take about 5 hours at 78ºF.At the end of proofing, the dough should double and feel full of air. If you take a floured finger and gently poke it, it should leave a slight indentation.
- Bake:Preheat the oven to 400ºF.When the oven is preheated, beat an egg with a splash of water in a small bowl to make an egg wash. Brush the top of the proofed brioche dough with a light egg wash.Place the brioche into the oven and immediately turn the oven temperature down to 350ºF.Bake for 45 minutes at 350ºF or until the top of the dough is golden brown. The internal temperature should read 195-205ºF.1 Egg, 1 tsp Water
- Remove the brioche from the oven and let it cool for about five minutes in the pan.Turn the loaf out of the pan and let cool completely on a wire rack for at least an hour.Pull apart, slice & enjoy!
This is my first attempt at an enriched dough and am a fairly beginner sourdough baker (1 year experience).
I seriously almost threw out my dough at first because it didn’t seem right. I did add more flour and barely got a dough “ball.” And after kneading for twice the length of time recommended it would just tear and was not close to windowpane. I felt defeated but ultimately decided to go through the rest of the process.
However after bulk ferment with a couple S&Fs and quite a while in the fridge (about noon to the next morning) it felt much better and I shaped it into my pans. (Made a double) I rose them for three or four hours in my oven’s bread proof setting (95deg) and baked them and OH MY GOSH I am so glad I did not give up!!
It is divine!
I do, however, prefer my brioche a bit sweeter than this. Does anyone know if I can simply add more sugar? And how much?
Thank you for this recipe. My only complaint is my family devoured it within one hour. 🤣
Hi Carolyn, thank you for not giving up! Brioche definitely continues to gain strength during fermentation and with some extra folds, it’ll come together. You can always feel free to add a bit more sugar if you’d like depending on your sweetness level. I always say to start small (a couple of TBS at a time) and test your way up to your preference.
Oh no, I’ll be forced to “taste” so many loaves of brioche – for science! 🤓
Thanks for your reply!
I want to make this for thanksgiving. I know it says it is best the day of but thinking I may need to make ahead and freeze. Or should I just refrigerate the dough and bake before serving ? Thanks. Janet
It stores well! I’d bake, slice, freeze, and reheat or freeze the whole loaf, thaw overnight in the fridge, tent with foil, and reheat at 350ºF for 15-20 minutes or until it’s heated through.
I’m making this for the second time but with different flour and I too had to add extra flour for it to pull away from the sides of the bowl. Right now it’s been sitting in a proof box for two hours, I’ve done the folding bit twice, and for the moment it hasn’t risen one bit! I will continue to let it rise until I go to bed, but it just doesn’t feel right. On the other hand, the first time I made it with the type of flour I ran out of it turned out incredibly well, to the extent that I worried it rose too much. Will come back when the results are in.
Enriched doughs can take longer to rise, especially if any of the ingredients/dough are cold. It may need to proof longer, but as long as your starter is active, it’ll rise eventually.
Currently making this recipe and I can tell just by how the dough was towards the end of the mixing, that this is going to be amazing. Thank you for the thorough instructions and I also like how you put the ingredients in each step of your directions.
Appreciate that! I think you’ll love it!
I’m a huge fan of this web site but I’ve tried making this recipe 3 times and each time I ended up having to add upwards of 250 grams of Bread
Flour (I doubled the recipe each time so I’m wondering if that’s the issue?). Each time it is quite literally soup and doesn’t even come close to a dough mass until I add a lot more flour. It all has worked out after the flour addition but, after looking at the babka ratios (which I’ve also made at least 3x, and is absolute perfection), something is off with this recipe. Would love for you to remake it yourself with the flour as you write in here, and check to see if it turns to soup for you. I am using KA bread flour.
I’m sorry to hear you haven’t had success with this brioche bread. I make it often and while the dough is quite sticky at first, it does come together. I actually use the same base for my cinnamon rolls and dinner roll recipes. I also use King Arthur Bread flour, so I’m thinking it may have something to do with how soft your butter is (should be room temp) or the amount of liquid being added in the milk/yudane. I use large eggs that are about 55g each if you want to get really precise. But since you’ve had issues, I would recommend using my babka base and just make it the exact same way instead and you’ll still get a delicious brioche!
Okay, yes start with a little less milk in the recipe and maybe substitute one egg yolk for one of the eggs and hopefully that help reduce some of the liquid for you! It definitely shouldn’t be soupy, but will be quite loose and shaggy and first.